"Standing
in the middle of the road is very dangerous; you get knocked down by the traffic
from both sides." - Margaret Thatcher (quoted on page 158)
It
seems that no one knows how to understand James Comey. He is castigated by those on both sides of
the political divide and by many in between.
Hillary Clinton blames him for her loss of the election; Donald Trump
calls him a "slimeball." And
yet when he appears in interviews on TV, (and he's had a lot of them) he seems
earnest and sincere.
James
Comey is probably best known as the 6'-8" director of the FBI, who was
fired in May of 2017 by President Donald Trump.
He was appointed to that position by Barack Obama, and had previously
served as Deputy Attorney General under George W. Bush, and before that as
assistant U. S. Attorney and U. S. Attorney for the Southern District of New
York. He has had a long history of
service, although many only know of him from his appearances on the TV news
programs.
After
it seemed Comey had receded to the background of the news cycle, he began
reappearing, promoting the release of his book, A Higher Loyalty - Truth,
Lies and Leadership. He appeared in
interviews by many of the TV newspersons as well as some of the late night
comics. Reactions by the interviewers
were mixed, generally relaxed, though some almost sounded prosecutorial and
Stephen Colbert's seemed actually congenial.
But
many of the critical comments on his book were almost malicious. It was called "bitchy;" it "torches
what's left of his own reputation."
Comey "surrenders the high ground," he "descends to Trump's
level" [as if that were possible]; he lets "Trump, once again get the
better of him;" he lowers himself to Trump's "sordid level;"
"showing that his judgment is flawed." All these, coming from the print media, both left
and right seemed to contradict our early impressions of Comey as reasonable,
honest and sincere.
So
of course, Uni and I had to read his book.
And we somehow did not come away with the same impressions that the news
commentators did. The book in a sense,
defies categorization - it is a memoir; it is an apologetic; it is a treatise
on personal ethics; and of course it has much to say about our political
situation in America, while attempting to be apolitical. It is a book, as the author lets us know,
about truth. Comey lets us know
the inadequacy he feels in writing a book about "ethical leadership,"
but feels that truth is under fire in America today and that this is "a
time when examination of ethical leadership would be useful." He tells us "... there is a higher loyalty
in all of our lives...The higher loyalty is to lasting values, most important
the truth."
The
early chapters are well-written, fascinating reading. Comey relates many details of his childhood,
youth and college experiences that he apparently believes have brought him to
where he is today. Bullied as a child
(he was not an early bloomer), threatened with a gun by a burglar; taking part
in bullying himself in college; all these actions making an impression that
would last. He tells of those who
mentored or had an early influence on him.
One who apparently made an impact on him was a grocer named Harry
Howell, of whom he said, "Looking back, even after working for presidents
and other prominent leaders in and outside government, I still think Harry
Howell was one of the finest bosses I have ever had." (page 34). Quite a statement considering the many other
well known figures mentioned.
While
the book is filled with many examples of positive leadership style, there are
also a few who serve as bad examples.
The mafia leaders he dealt with as Assistant U. S. Attorney, whose
leadership style was based on personal loyalty, the mafia killers whom he dealt
with who could justify their actions and appear to be otherwise normal people,
of whom he commented, "Evil has an ordinary face. It laughs, it cries, it deflects, it
rationalizes, it makes great pasta." (page 27).
Then
there was the influence of his wife.
"But the person who taught me the most about leadership is my wife,
Patrice." (page 43). He tells of
their struggles with the early death of their son and of Patrice's campaign for
early testing for Group B streptococcus which had killed him, and of the wisdom
in dealing with God and suffering that she had taught James.
Which
brought up to us James Comey's faith. Uni
said, "He must be a Christian ... or at least he talks and acts like a
Christian ought to." We spent much
time and conversation on this topic. Religion
was his second major as a college undergraduate. He quotes Reinhold Niebuhr and Martin
Luther. The paragraph on "God's
role in human history" on page 47 reflects deep thought on God.
One
could read this book superficially, simply as a series of episodes of adventure
in the crime fighting profession. We
like the casual "name-dropping" and the roles he played in many
national political crises. His clash
with some of President Bush's people, even his confrontation with the President
himself, where he quoted Martin Luther, "Here I stand. I can do no other." (page 96).
Yet
James Comey did his best to avoid politics.
His concern was always "to do the right thing." He speaks as one totally committed to truth
and justice. "I don't care about
politics. I don't care about
expediency. I don't care about
friendship. I care about doing the right
thing. And I would never be part of
something that I believe to be fundamentally wrong. I mean, obviously we all make policy
judgments where people disagree, but I will do the right thing." (page
94), an excerpt from his confirmation hearing was taped by his wife to the
refrigerator door.
We
also get the idea that he had a great amount of respect for both President Bush,
under whom he served as Deputy Attorney General and President Obama,.who appointed
him as FBI Director. He seemed to
actually like them both and wanted them to succeed, while at the same time
avoiding politics.
Of
course, nearly the entire second half of the volume is taken up with matters
that are still discussed in the daily news:
Hillary Clinton's e-mail investigation, the Russian influence on the
2016 election and of course his relations with, and firing by Donald
Trump. I suppose that this was the main
reason many purchased this book. The
pundits of course homed in on this part of Comey's story and then criticized as
mentioned above, also complaing that the book adds nothing to our knowledge of
the current soap opera in Washington.
However,
as for Uni and me, our motives for reading were not those of the pundits. We both felt that here was a man with whom we
could empathize, a man who sought to always "do the right thing" even
at personal cost. We felt that with all
the lies and self-serving that accompany the current series of scandals, here
was one man who stood above the crowd (and not just physically).
Yes,
his remarks about Donald Trump are harsh, but nowhere do they descend to the level
of that man. His warnings to America are
not sour-grapes or the angry reactions of his firing. We agree with him that "Donald Trump's
presidency threatens much of what is good in this nation," and that the
adulation of "so-called conservative commentators, including some faith leaders
... strikes me (and us) as both hypocritical and morally wrong." (page 25).
We
believe that one reason there is so much criticism of James Comey is that very
few of his critics, right or left, have ever met a man who is totally committed
to "do the right thing," who believes in **a "higher
loyalty." And so they attack his
person, and even worse, his motives.
Attacking a person's motives rather than his actions is wrong headed and seems to us to show that there are
no greater criticisms to levy.
We're
not saying that James Comey is beyond criticism. He may do something in the future to greatly
disappoint. But this book presents a man
who is exemplary in both his motives and behavior, a man who is humble enough
to examine himself - and he is much more honest in his self-evaluation than his
critics.
No comments:
Post a Comment