Wednesday, July 15, 2009

THE CASE AGAINST MARRIAGE

I came across an article with this title in the magazine THE WEEK. It is an excerpt from a larger essay (which I didn’t read) in THE ATLANTIC MONTHLY by Sandra Tsing Loh.

Ms. Loh describes her divorce after a 20-year marriage, as well as her friends’ gripes about their marriages and husbands. She quotes some statistics and a few experts and asks some very pointed questions:
 “Why do we still insist on marriage?”
 “But now that we have white-collar work and washing machines and our life expectancy has shot from 47 to 77, isn’t the idea of lifelong marriage obsolete?”

She makes a few suggestions and concludes, “In any case, my final piece of advice is straightforward: Avoid marriage – or you too may suffer the emotional pain, the humiliation, and the logistical difficulty of breaking up a long-term union in midlife.”

Is she right? Is she on to something? Have Uni and I been pursuing the wrong course for all these (nearly) 53 years? Did I do wrong in marrying those dozens of couples in my years in the ministry? (Apparently some of them thought so – they didn’t all take!) Did I do wrong in counseling all those couples to be faithful and to stay married? Would we all have been better off single?

I don’t think so!

It is easier to be sympathetic, however, with Ms. Loh’s views when we look at them in their context. She lives in a world that is unfamiliar to me, but which I fear is encroaching more and more on that of my family and friends – even church friends.

Her world (it appears) consists of two career families, families where children seem to be more of a burden than a joy, where the “girls” have their “night,” where bored and boring sexual partners have long ago set aside their passion for one another. The passion has been gone so long that it’s not worth attempting to recover. God is nowhere to be found. Divorce is inevitable!

Maybe she’s right! If that’s what marriage is, then why bother? If the relationships we enter in order to find happiness bring nothing but boredom and grief, maybe they’re not worth entering!

But what’s the alternative? Boredom and grief alone? Multiple sex partners who can provide what has been called “recreational sex”? A lifetime of being impoverished, not only relationally but financially? (Obviously finances are not a problem to Ms. Loh.)

Most of us spend our lives in “the pursuit of happiness,” and, I believe, never has this been truer than it is today. We seek our own happiness in things, in careers and in our marriages. If our things don’t satisfy, we get more and better things. If our careers don’t satisfy, we quit and look for better ones. And if our marriages don’t satisfy, we quit and either look for a better one, or seek the benefits of marriage without the burden of commitment.

But the pursuit of happiness doesn’t work. Happiness must pursue us! If we make our personal happiness our main goal, we will never attain it. Happiness is a byproduct!

We all need to take a look at what Jesus said. And He was saying to all, “If anyone wants to come after Me, he needs to deny himself and pick up his cross every day and follow Me. For whoever wants to save his life will lose it, but whoever will lose his life for My sake, he will save it. For what is a person profited if he gains the whole world but loses or forfeits himself?” (Luke 9:23-25)

This is the great paradox of the Christian life. When we seek our own life -- our gain, profit, happiness -- we don’t find it. When we give our life away for Him, we really find it.

And this applies in marriage. If we enter marriage expecting it and our partner to bring us happiness, we will be sadly disappointed. It’s not first of all about me – my happiness. It’s about a commitment to Jesus Christ and to our partner. It’s about seeking their happiness. And it’s about finding happiness – finding life – through giving it!

It’s worth the bother!

Bill Ball
7/15/2009

6 comments:

Sherry said...

I can relate to both worlds after two divorces, lots of dating and finally a marriage that "took".

I'd like to address Ms. Loh from a NON-biblical perspective:

Marriage is hard work but we never seem to realize it til it's required of us. If you're unwilling to work hard, avoid marriage. But being single can be hard work too (trust me - try dating again after being out of it for a long time - YIKES!!).

Marriage has rough spots. If you're only in it for good times, avoid marriage. But being single has rough spots too and no one there to share them with.

Yes. Marriage and parenthood can give you pain. If you're the type of person who avoids pain at all cost, then avoid marraige. But don't expect to be pain-free by being single.

Kids are difficult sometimes (ask my Dad) but they can also overwhelm you with feelings you never even dreamed you could have.

The solution if each option can be hard work, rough, painful and difficult at times is obviously not to avoid one and embrace the other.

It is rather to find the best way to be married, if you are, or the best way to be single, if you are.

And that's where we come to the Christian perspective on life which Dad is much better at explaining than I.

Living A Liturgy said...

When Josh and I were in marriage counseling, our counselor said something to the affect that marriage truly is a Christian thing - it only has complete meaning within that context. Marriage calls us to be self-sacrificing, look out for the needs of others, to always put others above ourselves - and God calls many people to that vocation. So in a non-Christian world (and sadly, in the Christian world too) divorce is inevitable. They have no binding covenant with each other and GOD to keep them together. Why should they stay together?

For the Christian, though, it is a different matter. Christ tells us he hates divorce and if a couple divorces and remarries, they commit adultery - it is no small matter.

Another thing our counselor advised is that if we are going into this with any thought that divorce could be an option that we shouldn't get married because divorce will become an option. Obviously, divorce is not an option for us. :)

Interesting thoughts, Opa!!

Jacq said...

I can only imagine what 53 years of marriage will be like, especially since I am only on month 6 :)

I take heart in the fact that marriage was created and glorifying to God, and Vasilis and I discover everyday that marriage draws us more to Christ. Thank you for your insight, we look up to you and Uni so much!

Hope all is well with you both!

dr suesss said...

Thank you Uncle bill for the Blog. Marriage is just that a bond between the good and the bad. You will always get out of the marriage what you put into to it. A wise person told me that never go to bed angry. Thanks Mom.

Trey Scofield said...

Terry and I are still married!! You married us 18 years ago this coming August. You counseled us for many weeks before that marriage, and you said it would not be easy - you were correctamundo!

Worth it, you betcha, every last bit of it!!

Bill Ball said...

Thanks, Trey. I'm never certain if a marriage is going to work -- but I praise God, yours did. (I did a lot of praying.) Give Terry a big hug for me.